A Few Clouds
63°FA Few CloudsFull Forecast

Republicans block Obama nominee to appeals court

Published: Wednesday, March 6, 2013 12:50 p.m. CDT
Caption
(JIM MCKNIGHT)
FILE - This April 27, 2005 file photo shows Caitlin J. Halligan, in the Court of Appeals in Albany, N.Y. Senate Republicans on Wednesday blocked the confirmation of federal appeals court nominee Caitlin Halligan for the second time, denying President Barack Obama a key judicial appointment. (AP Photo/Jim McKnight)

WASHINGTON (AP) — Senate Republicans on Wednesday blocked the confirmation of federal appeals court nominee Caitlin Halligan for the second time, denying President Barack Obama a key judicial appointment.

A majority of senators, 51, supported Halligan's nomination, but Democrats needed 60 votes in the 100-member Senate to get it past Republican objections.

Citing her work on lawsuits against gun manufacturers and on behalf of illegal immigrants, Republicans said Halligan is too liberal to sit on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia. The National Rifle Association opposed her nomination.

Obama said he was "deeply disappointed" in the Senate's action.

"Ms. Halligan has always practiced law with the highest ethical ideals, and her qualifications are beyond question," Obama said. "Furthermore, her career in public service and as a law enforcement lawyer, serving the citizens of New York, is well within the mainstream."

Democrats said the effort to block Halligan, who was first nominated to the appeals court in September 2010 to fill the seat vacated by John Roberts when he was elevated to chief justice of the Supreme Court in 2005, also is about maintaining a conservative majority on a key appellate court. GOP senators blocked the confirmation vote on her in December 2011 and Obama renominated her in January this year.

There are currently four vacancies on the court, with nominees from Republican presidents holding a slim, 4-3 majority. The D.C. appeals court is considered one of the most important courts in the country because it handles challenges to most federal rulemaking and oversees federal agencies based in Washington.

The Washington court is also something of a pipeline to the Supreme Court. Four of the nine the justices on the Supreme Court served on the D.C. Circuit before being confirmed to the higher court: Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas and Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

"Lets call it for what it is," said Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., supporting Halligan's nomination. "This has to do with keeping a court with the same views."

Republicans defended their votes to block Halligan, saying they objected to Halligan in particular, not the idea of a Democratic nominee to the key court. Citing her work as the state of New York's solicitor general, Sen. Charles Grassley said Halligan could not be trusted.

"This is a court where we can least afford to nominate an activist judge," he said.

Republican Leader Mitch McConnell called Halligan's former work as solicitor general for the state of New York "a textbook example of judicial activism."

Halligan is now general counsel in the Manhattan District Attorney's Office.

Sen. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska was the only Republican who voted in favor of advancing Halligan's nomination. Senate Democratic Leader Harry Reid of Nevada switched his vote to side with Republicans near the end of the roll call as a parliamentary move that allows him to bring her nomination up again for a vote sometime in the future.

Previous Page|1|2|Next Page

Get breaking and town-specific news sent to your phone. Sign up for text alerts from the Northwest Herald.

More News

Reader Poll

How much will you spend on school supplies?
Nothing
Less than $100
$100-$199
$200-$299
$300 or more