Ill. labor unions sue over plan to cut pensions

SPRINGFIELD – Labor unions filed a lawsuit Tuesday seeking to throw out Illinois' new law aimed at eliminating a worst-in-the-nation pension shortfall, a long-anticipated move that could delay implementation of the landmark measure.

Lawyers for a coalition of unions filed the lawsuit in Sangamon County Circuit court. The lawsuit, which follows others already filed by retirees, argues the pension bill approved by the Legislature and signed by Gov. Pat Quinn more than a month ago violates a clause of the state constitution that says pension benefits may not be cut. It also asks the court to stop the law from taking effect until the case is decided.

In a press release, Michael Carrigan, president of the Illinois AFL-CIO, said the suit "makes it clear that pension theft is not only unfair, it's clearly unconstitutional."

"The Legislature and governor shirked their responsibility to uphold the constitution," Carrigan said, adding "promises must be kept, and the rule of law must prevail over politics."

The We Are One Illinois coalition of unions, which lobbied against the plan, filed the lawsuit ahead of Quinn's annual State of the State address Wednesday, where he is expected to tout the pension overhaul as a major achievement.

Illinois' five public-retirement systems were $100 billion short of what was needed to meet the state's obligations to workers and retirees when the Legislature passed the measure. Its supporters say the plan will reduce that unfunded liability by about $21 billion and fully fund the pension systems by 2044. They estimate it will save the state about $160 billion over the next three decades.

The plan reduces the annual cost-of-living increases for retirees and raises the retirement age for workers 45 and younger. It also puts some savings back into the pension funds and directs money from pension bond payments to the retirement systems after those bonds are paid off in 2019.

Illinois' pension problem was the result of decades of lawmakers skipping or shorting payments to the systems. As the unfunded liability grew, so did the state's annual payments. This year they reached about $6 billion — or one-fifth of the general funds budget — an amount that siphoned money away from schools, social services and other areas. The shortfall also caused the major credit rating agencies to downgrade Illinois to the lowest credit rating of any state.

Still, lawmakers in the Democrat-controlled Legislature failed for years to come up with a deal to solve it. In late November, following months of meetings of a bipartisan conference committee, the four legislative leaders emerged from closed-door negotiations and said they had reached an agreement. Less than a week later, the House and Senate returned to Springfield and approved the plan.

However, the law has already undergone legal challenges.

In early January, the Illinois State Employees Association Retirees and the Retired State Employees Association filed class-action lawsuits in Sangamon County Circuit Court on behalf of their members. They contend the law violates a provision of the state constitution that says pension benefits may not be diminished. They also claim the law is unfair to retirees who made required contributions to their retirement funds, while Illinois did not.

Quinn and other supporters of the law say it was critical to getting the state back on solid financial footing and predicted the Illinois Supreme Court will ultimately uphold it. To bolster their case, they included an unusual three-page preamble on the legislation that lays out the state's bleak financial picture.

Lawmakers also included two components they say were intended to improve the plan's odds of surviving a legal challenge: a 1 percent decrease in employee contributions and a funding guarantee, which allows the systems to sue the state if lawmakers don't provide Illinois' payments to the accounts.

But public-employee unions and other critics say the law is unfair to workers and retirees who for years made their contributions to the funds while the state did not.

Among the other changes included in the law is a cap of about $110,000 on the annual salary on which a pension may be based. The plan also gives some workers the option of freezing their pension and participating in a 401(k)-style defined contribution plan, and prohibits non-government employees such as union bosses from collecting a pension.

Loading more

Digital Access

Digital Access
Access from all your digital devices and receive breaking news and updates from around the area.

Home Delivery

Home Delivery
Local news, prep sports, Chicago sports, local and regional entertainment, business, home and lifestyle, food, classified and more! News you use every day! Daily, weekend and Sunday packages.

Text Alerts

Text Alerts
Stay connected to us wherever you are! Get breaking news updates along with other area information sent to you as a text message to your wireless device.

Email Newsletters

Email Newsletters
We'll deliver news & updates to your inbox. Plan your weekend and catch up on the news with our newsletters.